What is it about?
Gentili defines a perfect war as a public conflict waged between sovereign states. This definition excludes brigandage, piracy, and civil wars from its legal framework. He also divides war into three distinct phases—going to war, fighting the war, and making peace—giving the law of war the essential vocabulary needed to regulate complex military operations systematically. The article critically assesses this conceptual move. On the one hand, by viewing war as a dispute-settlement mechanism between equal sovereigns rather than a punishment for wrongdoing, Gentili advanced the idea of "bilateral justice" in war, which helped humanize both warfare and peace treaties. Gentili’s insistence that both sides deserve equal legal standing during combat (ius in bello) fostered modern humanitarian principles. Gentili's theory attempts to humanize warfare also by distinguing the combatants from the non-combatants and by humanizing the treatment of the prisoners of war. On the other hand, however, Gentili broadened the definition of legitimate self-defense to include pre-emptive strikes against perceived future threats. This lowers the threshold for initiating conflict and encourages opportunistic wars under the guise of prevention. Moreover, Gentili’s state-centric framework directly anticipates the core legal dilemmas of modern asymmetric warfare. Because bilateral justice restricts "perfect war" to equal, sovereign states, conflicts between states and non-state actors—such as insurgents, guerrilla fighters, or transnational militants—fall into a legal gray zone. Historically and today, this framing has been used to bypass standard prisoner-of-war protections.
Featured Image
Photo by Mario Gogh on Unsplash
Why is it important?
Examining Alberico Gentili’s early modern theory of war is essential today because the current international legal system is built directly on his state-centric foundation. The United Nations Charter relies on a Gentilian model of sovereign equality, meaning its rules are designed primarily to prevent wars between nations. As modern conflicts increasingly shift away from traditional state-versus-state battles, the hidden flaws in Gentili's 16th-century framework have become some of the most urgent legal challenges in global politics. For instance, modern international law still struggles to assign legal responsibility and combatant status when states fight through shadowy proxies, like private military contractors and cyber-militias. Finally, studying his arguments reveals the long-standing legal risks of lowering the threshold for using force.
Perspectives
By depicting the lights and shadows of Gentili's theory of perfect war, this study can serve as a backbone for contemporary studies on the law of armed conflict. Understanding the "lights" reminds modern policymakers why certain rules—like international humanitarian law—were created in the first place. By studying Gentili’s "shadows," modern legal theorists can see that contemporary crises—such as the status of "unlawful combatants" or autonomous weapons—are not just new technological problems. They are structural flaws of the system that may require rethinking.
Professor Valentina Vadi
Universita degli Studi di Padova
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: Perfect War: Alberico Gentili on the Use of Force and the Early Modern Law of Nations, Grotiana, December 2020, Brill,
DOI: 10.1163/18760759-41020002.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page







