What is it about?

This article discusses the social origins and dynamics of the ways we form mental models and short cuts (heuristics) in our judgement and decisions. Using the situated cognition framework, that is, judgements and decisions take place in a socio-material context with particular histories and extant social, economic and cultural resources, we demonstrate how retail investors and brokers in a market come to pass narrative judgments about market volatility, and act on them. We then relate these judgments to well-known short-cuts such as representativeness and anchoring, and biases such as overconfidence. We also discuss their potential econometric effects such as co-movements among markets.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

We go beyond asocial accounts of heuristics and biases, which are generated mainly in experimental settings. We demonstrate how socio-material dynamics in a given social setting shape universally latent heuristics and biases in our minds, with particular outcomes for particular settings. We also demonstrate how naturally occurring narratives can be collected and analysed to study heuristics and biases.

Perspectives

Behavioural approaches to economic and financial decision-making have gained unprecedented recognition owing to Nobel-prize-winning theories. In this paper, we demonstrate how these behavioural insights manifest themselves in any social environment, including financial markets. Social environments are formed of identities, endowments (i.e., social, cultural and economic capital) and associated preferences and decisions that are historically formed and institutionalised. Studying social dynamics can enrich behavioural insights on decision-making .

Dr Emre Tarim
Lancaster University

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Situated cognition and narrative heuristic: evidence from retail investors and their brokers, European Journal of Finance, November 2013, Taylor & Francis,
DOI: 10.1080/1351847x.2013.858054.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page