What is it about?

The paper examines the impact of online peer-to-peer accommodation platforms (like Airbnb) on the well-being and social sustainability of local communities, focusing on Barcelona, Spain. Using the Human Scale Development (HSD) approach, the study investigates how such platforms contribute to social issues like loss of community cohesion, displacement, rising housing costs, and neighborhood identity loss. It underscores that social sustainability is critical to tourism's economic sustainability, highlighting that local residents experience increased discomfort and conflict due to tourism pressures. The authors argue for a regulatory framework that incorporates resident input, addresses community needs, and establishes cooperative relationships among institutions, tourists, residents, and businesses to maintain social balance and sustainability. The study identifies factors impacting residents' attitudes toward tourism, such as inadequate regulation, the erosion of local culture, and prioritization of economic gains over social welfare. The findings advocate for public policies that support neighborhood cohesion, empower resident associations in decision-making, and set limits on tourist accommodations to preserve residents' quality of life and ensure tourism does not compromise social structures.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

This study is important because it highlights the often-overlooked social costs of the rapid expansion of online tourist rentals in residential neighborhoods. While platforms like Airbnb bring economic benefits and broaden accommodation options for tourists, they can also disrupt local communities. This disruption includes increased housing costs, loss of neighborhood cohesion, and a shift in local culture that can lead to residents feeling displaced or overlooked. Understanding these impacts is crucial for cities that rely on tourism, as it emphasizes that sustainable tourism requires not only economic growth but also social balance and community well-being. By advocating for more inclusive regulations that take residents' voices into account, this study offers insights for policymakers to create tourism models that respect the needs and lifestyles of local communities.

Perspectives

Resident Perspective: The rapid increase in tourist rentals affects community cohesion, housing affordability, and neighborhood character. Residents often feel their needs are sidelined in favor of economic interests. The study highlights their desire for regulations that protect their quality of life, including restrictions on tourist accommodations and maintaining neighborhood spaces for locals. This perspective stresses the need for a balanced approach where tourism does not overpower the social fabric of residential areas. Policymaker Perspective: For cities reliant on tourism, this study underscores the importance of socially sustainable policies. Policymakers are encouraged to engage residents in decision-making, creating frameworks that manage tourism growth while preserving community stability. The study suggests that integrating resident feedback into policies can enhance local support for tourism and reduce resistance or "tourism-phobia," as seen in high-pressure destinations like Barcelona. Tourism Industry Perspective: The industry benefits from maintaining positive relations with local communities, as tourism’s long-term viability depends on its social acceptance. This perspective suggests that the industry should consider cooperative models with local communities and support policies that ensure a balanced tourism-resident relationship. Sustainable tourism practices that respect community needs are essential for the industry’s credibility and longevity. Sustainability Perspective: The study emphasizes that sustainable tourism must account for economic, environmental, and social dimensions equally. Social sustainability is especially crucial, as neglecting the community's well-being could lead to a fragile tourism model that ultimately undermines both economic and social goals. This perspective advocates for a holistic view of sustainability, where resident satisfaction is foundational to tourism's future success. Human Scale Development (HSD) Perspective: This study applies the HSD approach, which centers on human needs like protection, participation, and identity. This perspective provides a framework for balancing economic activities with community well-being, offering practical recommendations for creating a socially sustainable tourism model that can be applied to other urban areas experiencing similar pressures.

Juan F. Prados-Castillo
Universidad de Granada

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Interferences generated on the well-being of local communities by the activity of online platforms for tourist accommodation, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, December 2020, Taylor & Francis,
DOI: 10.1080/09669582.2020.1861455.
You can read the full text:

Read

Resources

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page