What is it about?

Drawing on research with activists who traveled to Greece during the 2015–2016 "refugee crisis," this article explores the hopes, longings, bewilderment, and contradictions involved in trying to help and make a meaningful difference. It introduces the idea of mattering the world, a framework for understanding how our capacities to act emerge through our relationships, the world around us and along imaginative, affective, developmental horizons of possibility. Challenging the assumption that taking action requires strength, independence, and control, the article argues that vulnerability is fundamental to our capacity to act and respond to injustice. It concludes that acknowledging and working with vulnerability is essential to preserving this capacity to respond.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

At a time of overlapping political, social, ecological, and humanitarian crises, questions about how people respond to injustice and suffering are increasingly urgent. Yet common understandings of political action often emphasize individual motivation, rational action, and strength, overlooking the complex emotional, relational, imaginative, and material conditions that make action possible. This article challenges the assumption that being vulnerable means being less capable of acting. It shows how vulnerability is a fundamental part of engagement with the world, bringing into focus the existential need to act on the world as part of realizing ourselves within it. This recognition can help to rethink what it means to act responsibly in situations of crisis, particularly when one is implicated in the very conditions that call for change. It also invites us to consider how communities, movements, and organizations might better recognize and support the vulnerabilities inherent in efforts toward social and political change.

Perspectives

The ideas in this article emerged out of a frustrating process of feeling perpetually dissatisfied with the account of activists' experiences I was producing by relying on conventional conceptual frames of 'motivation' and 'decisions to act.' The logic of these frames simply could not account for or do justice to the longing, imagination, bewilderment, guilt, and complicated relationships through which activists engaged in this crisis. In this way, the notion of mattering the world emerged from this struggle and the article traces the often painful but rewarding process of epistemological and theoretical reorientation. I hope that the ideas in my article help to support thoughtful and nuanced conversations about vulnerability and care without shifting attention away from those most directly affected by injustice or obscuring the unequal relations of power within which acts of solidarity take place.

Kate Sheese
Sigmund Freud University Berlin

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Mattering the world: Toward a vulnerable retheorization of political agency in crises and complicity., Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology, November 2026, American Psychological Association (APA),
DOI: 10.1037/teo0000373.
You can read the full text:

Read

Resources

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page