What is it about?

Despite widespread discussion around college safety, many universities still lack proactive threat management systems and rely on traditional crime statistics (like Clery Act data) that fail to capture a school's actual safety readiness. Motivated by preventable campus tragedies—such as the 2018 murder of student-athlete Lauren McCluskey—this study introduces and evaluates a new evaluation tool called the Campus Safety Score. Rather than just counting past crimes, the tool holistically measures campus safety across four main areas: safety policies and threat assessment training (50%), crime data (20%), student safety perceptions (20%), and institutional safety culture (10%). Based on in-depth interviews with experts in criminal justice, counseling, higher education administration, and risk assessment, the study shows that a standardized score serves as a powerful diagnostic tool—helping colleges spot safety gaps, advocate for security funding, and adopt life-saving best practices.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

Existing campus safety rankings and reporting mechanisms (such as Clery Act disclosures) are largely backward-looking, counting past incidents rather than evaluating an institution's proactive prevention capabilities. Many commercial safety scores also lack methodological transparency or ignore student safety perceptions altogether. This study introduces a unique, SME-vetted 4-part framework that prioritizes actionable threat assessment, policies, and training (50%), institutional culture (10%), crime statistics (20%), and community perceptions (20%). With colleges facing mounting pressure to address intimate partner violence, stalking, and targeted threats, universities often struggle with implementation gaps and under-resourced threat management teams. This research provides university leaders, risk managers, and insurers with a diagnostic tool to identify hidden safety gaps and justify funding for prevention resources. Crucially, it empowers prospective students and families with transparent, objective data to make informed enrollment decisions while encouraging institutions to adopt life-saving safety practices.

Perspectives

This research is deeply personal. Motivated by the tragic and preventable murder of Lauren McCluskey, our goal was to turn profound grief and institutional failure into systemic, lasting reform. Through this work, I wanted to address a painful reality in higher education: warning signs of dating violence and stalking are too often missed because campus units operate in silos or lack specialized threat assessment training. Creating a standardized Campus Safety Score is more than an academic exercise—it is a moral imperative to ensure institutions are held accountable before tragedy strikes, honoring Lauren's legacy by building safer, truly proactive campus communities.

Nicole Drumhiller
Washington State University

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Creating incentives for threat management best practices: The creation of a campus safety score., Journal of Threat Assessment and Management, November 2026, American Psychological Association (APA),
DOI: 10.1037/tam0000293.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page