What is it about?

Trust in institutions is at historic lows. What does that do to the kind of leaders people want? Across 10 preregistered studies with more than 7,000 participants in eight countries, we show that distrusting institutions creates an internal conflict: people still believe institutions should serve everyone’s interests, yet see them failing to do so. This cognitive conflict heightens the need for consistency, and one way to satisfy it is to prefer leaders who take a clear side rather than weigh competing views. Under institutional distrust, even the mental image of a “typical leader” (captured in images with a computer vision technique) looks more one-sided.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

Most research on declining trust looks at its causes or its political consequences. We look at the psychological process: distrust does not just change what people feel about institutions, it changes what they find appealing in a leader. This means that distrust could feed polarization. Our findings also point to a way out. When the need for consistency is satisfied in other ways, for instance by reflecting on core values and goals, the pull toward one-sided leaders disappears. That matters for leaders in politics and business who must acknowledge real trade-offs in front of audiences that crave certainty.

Perspectives

This project grew out of a simple observation: institutional distrust is pervasive in the news, yet we knew little about what this specific case of distrust does to the way people think. Linking a classic idea from social psychology, cognitive dissonance, to today’s crisis of trust helped us make sense of a puzzle: distrust pushes people toward certainty rather than toward lowering their expectations of institutions. The reverse-correlation study, in which participants effectively “visualize” the face of the leader they prefer, is a part of the work I find particularlystriking. My hope is to raise awareness about the potential risk of institutional distrust for social cohesion.

Claire Linares
IESE Business School

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: How institutional distrust breeds one-sided leadership: A consistency-based account., Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, July 2026, American Psychological Association (APA),
DOI: 10.1037/pspi0000527.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page